The Women's Institute (WI) bucks the trend on brothels.
Mon 4th Aug 2008 – (3 Comments)
I've written on this subject before, and as such you may feel some element of repetition, however last night's program about the WI calling for safer spaces for prostitutes means now is the perfect time to talk again about the decriminalisation of the work and indeed how counter-productive the talk Harriet Harman gave at the beginning of the year is.
If you missed the show then I'm sure it'll be repeated but between this report and this one you get a good idea of what went on. I will say right now that I was absolutely surprised and was glad to have some of my perceptions shook, not in that of the brothels around the world and how they operate, but that those whom I assumed would be naturally opposed to prostitution (being the WI) were actually extremely tuned in to the necessity for promoting safety and rights in the "trade".
I said it in the past, there is no reasonable argument for not at least exploring/trialling a legalisation of brothels. I would not be surprised that the police and authorities in areas with brothels running illegally, such as one shown in the show, know exactly what is going on but don't intervene unless they cause a wider social problem in the area. If this is the case, as I believe it to be, then it is a hypocritical situation to be in.
I can't blame the police, and in all fairness if they are making such a stance on operational grounds I applaud them as it only makes sense to put your resources where it's needed. But is it really just that the women in those brothels can't rely on those same people for protection if something goes wrong? On all sides, women working, the police, even owners of brothels that wish to be reputable, they're having their hands tied to create a bad situation.
I understand there is an argument some have, particularly feminists, that prostitution is an oppressive and misogynistic practice that is inherently degrading to women. It's an opinion, one I don't agree with, but summarily misses the reality of the situation when those same people call for more clamp downs on prostitution such as Harriet Harman suggested. If you care about women's rights and equality then the way to achieve that is not to force those that are already being persecuted, oppressed and forced to do things they don't like to be treated further as criminals (and let's not kid ourselves that by just criminalising the male side women involved won't by proxy become more criminal). To clamp down and be tougher on this "industry" would only hurt the rights of the females involved, make them less accessible to the support they need and further push money into the hands of true criminals and sex traffickers.
Feminists against this type of work, and other prostitution haters, get on board this campaign like the WI have, support the Hampshire WI in trying to get this resolution for safer spaces for working girls passed in the 2009 national WI conference. Then once we've started to achieve a situation where criminal involvement in prostitution is squeezed out through regulation, and safety is increased for those involved, we can start to argue about the more lofty issues of misogyny being promoted through the sex industry. At least that way many more women won't be being beaten, raped, murdered and left with life long diseases while you fail to get off your high horses.
Comments
2. Lee Griffin - 4 Aug 2008 - 12:05
No, I agree completely. I said in my previous article that we’d be naive to think legalisation would solve all the problems...but at least we’d be solving some of them. I think that is ultimately why the government is against the idea of legalisation though, ultimately it means they have to start taking responsibility for a section of society that the sun readership don’t care about.
By proxy this also means that they have to take an element of responsibility for their welfare. Just why anyone believes government *shouldn’t* be taking some responsibility for their welfare already is beyond me.
[Subject] StateDemocracy.org Equips You for the 2008 Elections
Dear Citizen:
Are you ready yet for the November 4th Elections? How about your friends, family, and neighbors?
More Americans are expected to vote this year than ever before in history, so don’t be left out! Be sure to ask everyone you know the following questions:
Are you registered to vote? If you moved recently, have you updated your voter registration?
Did you apply for an Absentee Ballot? Do you know your state may not require any reason?
Can you find your local Polling Place? Do you know it may have changed from last time?
The answers to these questions -- and all your voting needs -- can be found at www.StateDemocracy.org -- the FREE 1-Stop citizen empowerment portal that Delivers Democracy to your Desktop! StateDemocracy is among the Internet’s first (since 2001) and most encompassing civic empowerment tools.
In order to boost voter participation this year, StateDemocracy.org is offering FREE widgets for all 50 states. You can simply download and embed these widgets into your own website so your visitors can register to vote, get an absentee ballot or find their local polling place.
Lobby Congress Via StateDemocracy
StateDemocracy.org also equips you to maintain an active dialog with your state and federal lawmakers once they are elected. And RIGHT NOW is an especially opportune time to contact your U.S. Senators and House Member, as Congress takes up major legislation on such issues as offshore oil drilling, another economic stimulus package and all federal appropriations bills over the next few weeks.
As you lobby your elected officials, remember that lawmakers view your constituent input as reflective of scores of other citizens who felt similarly, but didn’t have (or take) the time to share their opinions.
LobbyDelegates.com Further Empowered Grassroots Voices
Over the past 5 months, you may have visited www.LobbyDelegates.com, along with 26,000 other visitors. This latest public interest portal by the StateDemocracy Foundation remained the only online tool enabling rank-and-file Democrats to lobby all 800+ Super Delegates on which candidate to back for the party’s Presidential nomination.
StateDemocracy Foundation Website Users Unite!
Many of you have used our StateDemocracy.org and LobbyDelegates.com tools in recent times, and have hopefully found your experience uplifting and empowering. I encourage all of you to help spread the news about StateDemocracy.org to enable more of our fellow citizens to Connect! Engage! And Empower!
Sincerely,
Ken Laureys, Executive Director
StateDemocracy Foundation
Ken.Laureys@StateDemocracy.org
P.S. If you are interested in becoming more involved in our StateDemocracy Foundation -- including volunteering as an Advisory Board Member -- please contact me.
Top 5:
Temporarily disabled to aid loading times
Latest Comments:
Andy in... How not to deal with the BNP
Rob W in... A minor victory for civil liberties - Re: RIPA
Lee Griffin in... The day I lost all faith in my country's authorities
Mark Reckons in... The day I lost all faith in my country's authorities
Lazy Students in... Drinking under 18 DOESN'T carry increased risks
Lee Griffin in... Welcome Back (edited) Jonathon Ross
Lucas in... Welcome Back (edited) Jonathon Ross
Labourboy in... Answer the bloody question, Brown
Compass Youth in... When equality is just as bad as inequality
Mark in... When equality is just as bad as inequality
Calendar:
| « August 2008 » | ||||||
| Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat | Sun |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | ||||
| 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
| 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 |
| 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 |
| 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 |
Search:
Best Blogs:
Temporarily disabled to aid loading times
Latest Politalks:
Temporarily disabled to aid loading times
Latest News:
Temporarily disabled to aid loading times
Categories:
Bloggers (21)
ebuzz (1)
Post (284)
--Art (1)
--Bloggers under attack (1)
--Comedy (3)
----Satire (4)
------Politalks (10)
--Community (5)
--Countries (0)
----Australia (1)
----China (2)
----Counties/Towns (0)
------Bristol (3)
------Cornwall (2)
----Darfur (3)
----EU (12)
----Iraq (1)
----Israel (1)
----Italy (1)
----Middle East (5)
----Palestine (1)
----USA (18)
--Critical response (26)
--Culture (3)
--Deaths (6)
--Demographics (1)
----Children (16)
------Boys (0)
------Girls (0)
------Yobs (7)
----Disability (2)
----Farmers (3)
----Pensioners (1)
--Disgusting traits (6)
----Apathy (4)
----Authoritarianism (35)
----Avoiding questions (12)
----Boring (2)
----Censorship (1)
----Clandestine (15)
----Discrimination (17)
----Fearmongering (1)
----Flip flopping (6)
----Forced worship (2)
----Hidden agenda (13)
----Hypocrisy (18)
----Immaturity (3)
----Misrepresentation (8)
----Moronic (19)
----Neglect (6)
----NIMBYism (3)
----Over-reaction (7)
----Petulance (3)
----Positive action (2)
----Prejudice (13)
----Selfishness (16)
----Undermining (8)
----Vigilantism (5)
----Vile (5)
----Xenophobia (3)
--False Priorities (27)
--Film (2)
--Gaming (5)
--Internet (7)
----P2P (3)
--Language (2)
--Lists (2)
--Long time coming (7)
--Music (2)
--Oddball (8)
--Organisations (1)
----BBC (12)
----BBFC (1)
----Carnival on Modern Liberty (1)
----Charity (2)
----Compass (1)
----Councils (5)
------Bristol Council (4)
----Dentists (3)
----FSA (1)
----ITV (1)
----Liberal Conspiracy (31)
------Casting the net (29)
----MAMAA (1)
----Mary Whitehouse (2)
----Media (30)
------Daily Mail (0)
------Grieving Widows (1)
------Guardian (0)
------Telegraph (1)
------The Sun (0)
------Times (1)
----Media Watch UK (1)
----National Lottery (1)
----NHS (8)
----NIAAA (1)
----No2ID (1)
----Northern Rock (5)
----Police (14)
----Television (2)
------Big Brother (1)
----Transport (9)
------First Bus (1)
------Oyster cards (1)
------Trains (1)
----Women\'s Institute (1)
--Other traits (0)
----Best practice (6)
----Common sense (7)
----Cool (0)
----Fairness (4)
----Honesty (4)
--Politics (134)
----Crime issues (18)
------Child Abuse (3)
------Justice (3)
------Knives (5)
------Law (13)
--------Data Protection Act (4)
--------Libel (1)
--------RIPA (1)
------Prohibition (7)
------Sex Offenders (1)
----Economic issues (17)
------Benefits (9)
------Budget (3)
------Fuel Poverty (6)
------Housing (6)
------Inflation (4)
------Minimum Wage (2)
------Money (37)
------Nationalisation (3)
------Poverty Line (2)
------Privatisation (2)
------Rich/Poor divide (5)
------Salaries (6)
------Taxes (18)
--------Windfall tax (1)
------Unemployment (5)
----Education issues (18)
------Schools (10)
--------Exclusions (1)
--------National Curriculum (5)
--------Teachers (2)
--------Truancy (2)
------Students (3)
--------Student Loans (2)
------University (5)
----Elections (29)
------Electoral reform (7)
------US Primaries 2008 (0)
----Ethical issues (4)
------Abortion (3)
------Age restrictions (4)
------Animal cruelty (4)
------Animal testing (1)
------Capital punishment (2)
------Copyright (0)
------Corporate Profits (2)
------Curfews (1)
------Deportation (2)
------Detention without charge (18)
------DNA (3)
------Equality (1)
------Feminism (1)
------File sharing (1)
------Free Speech (1)
------ID Cards (8)
------Organ donation (4)
------Prostitution (3)
--------Brothels (1)
------Surveillance (7)
--------CCTV (1)
------Terrorism (11)
----Families (1)
------Polygamy (1)
----Foreign issues (2)
------Military (5)
------Trafficking (1)
------War (3)
--------Illegal Munitions (1)
--------Warcrimes (1)
----Global issues (4)
------Climate change (11)
------Environment (11)
--------Energy (1)
----------Renewables (1)
----Liberalism (3)
----Local issues (3)
----Parliament (23)
------Bills (6)
--------Changing clocks (3)
--------Coroners and Justice Bill (5)
------Debate (3)
------House of Lords (1)
------MPs (7)
--------Alan Johnson (1)
--------Alistair Darling (2)
--------Backtracking (1)
--------Bill Rammell (2)
--------Boris Johnson (1)
--------Caroline Flint (3)
--------Chris Grayling (1)
--------David Cameron (14)
--------David Davis (1)
--------David Lammy (1)
--------Derek Conway (2)
--------Frank Field (0)
--------George Osbourne (0)
--------Gordon Brown (32)
--------Harriet Harperson (1)
--------Hazel Blears (2)
--------Jack Straw (2)
--------Jacqui Smith (15)
--------Julia Goldsworthy (1)
--------Keith Vaz (2)
--------Lynne Featherstone (1)
--------Maggie Thatcher (1)
--------MP Expenses (3)
--------Nick Clegg (14)
--------Norman Baker (1)
--------Norman Lamb (1)
--------Tim Yeo (1)
--------Vince Cable (3)
------PMQs (14)
------Written Questions (1)
----Personal issues (5)
------Age (4)
------Health issues (10)
--------Alcohol (13)
--------Food (10)
----------Fast Food (1)
--------Medicine (0)
----------MMR Vaccine (0)
--------Obesity (1)
--------Smoking (1)
------Patriotism (1)
------Sex (5)
------Work-life balance (1)
----Political Parties (2)
------Coalition (0)
------Democrats (10)
------Labour (46)
------Lib Dem (31)
------Rebellion (1)
------Republicans (5)
------Tory (30)
----Political vernacular (0)
------Balanced and Sustainable (2)
------Change (4)
------Crisis (2)
------Gimmick (2)
------Propaganda (4)
------Targets (10)
------Waste (4)
----Race issues (3)
------Immigration (8)
----Scandal (4)
------Cash for Amendments (1)
------Political donations (3)
----Strikes (0)
----UK Constitution (1)
--Protests (14)
----G20 2009 (3)
--Public engagement (10)
----Polls (7)
----Referendum (2)
--Public figures (0)
----Barack Obama (14)
----Baroness Warsi (1)
----Celebrity (2)
----Chief Medical Officer (1)
----Heath Ledger (2)
----Hillary Clinton (11)
----Ian Tomlinson (2)
----John Edwards (3)
----John McCain (0)
----Sarah Palin (0)
--Religion (9)
----Christianity (2)
----God squad (7)
----Hinduism (0)
----Islam (1)
--Sport (3)
----Olympics 2008 (4)
----Olympics 2012 (2)
----Paralympics 2008 (1)
--Statistics (14)
--Worrying trends (13)
Reviews (13)
Share (53)
About Lee: Former students' union president and intermitent blogger since the turn of the century, who's aim is to promote objective thinking and a break from partisan politics when discussing the issues of the day. 



1. Jennie Rigg - 4 Aug 2008 - 12:00
Lee, I am not against prostitution in principle, but the reality of it is horrendous. Like you, I think that most of this is down to prohibition, but it’s not exclusively so.
I’d like to see prostitution not only legalised, but properly regulated and inspected. Mere legalisation will not stop the abuses you refer to, if the authorities maintain a bargepole approach.